Tag: equity-and-inclusion

  • Values Under Pressure: The 2029 EPAS Draft and Social Work’s Words-to-Action Gap

    Table comparing the 2022 EPAS and the 2029 EPAS Draft. Anti-racism drops from 29 uses to 0, “diversity, equity, and inclusion” from 17 to 0, and oppression from 23 to 0. Fairness rises from 0 to 24, dignity from 2 to 26, and person-in-environment from 8 to 33.

    Public comment on the 2029 EPAS draft 1 closes at 11:59 p.m. Eastern on November 20, 2026. How to comment is at the end of this article.

    An Old Pattern in a New Document

    In 2022, the Council on Social Work Education told every accredited baccalaureate and master’s program in the country that social work education is grounded in “a commitment to anti-racism, diversity, equity, and inclusion.” The 2022 Educational Policy and Accreditation Standards (EPAS) wrote that commitment into the competencies students must demonstrate, the standards programs must meet, and the data programs must collect.

    The first draft of the 2029 EPAS still talks about justice. It talks about dignity, structural barriers, power, and human rights. What it weakens is the requirement to demonstrate specific forms of action: anti-racist and anti-oppressive practice, policy formulation and advocacy, and the use of evaluation findings to change practice.

    Let’s start with the words themselves. Here is how often the language of the profession’s justice commitments appears in each document.

    Term2022 EPAS2029 Draft 1
    Anti-racism / anti-racist290
    Oppression / oppressive / anti-oppressive230
    “Diversity, equity, and inclusion”170
    Diversity234
    Equity221
    Inclusion180
    Fair / fairness024
    Dignity226
    Respect725
    Person-in-environment833

    Counts exclude the 2022 table of contents. The 2029 draft is the longer document, because it adds practice doctorate standards.

    Any mention of racism or oppression has disappeared entirely. So has the phrase “diversity, equity, and inclusion.” Diversity survives four times, equity exactly once, and inclusion not at all. Instead, these core concepts and values have been replaced by the language of fairness, dignity, respect, and person-in-environment.

    Vocabulary alone would not make the case. Words can change while obligations hold. But in this draft, the words and the requirements move together.

    This pattern is not new. It is one we have seen time and time again.

    Social work has a habit. We make broad, public commitments to justice, and then we struggle to turn them into requirements that hold when those commitments become costly. Specht and Courtney documented one expression of this retreat more than thirty years ago in Unfaithful Angels. More recently, I examined a related contradiction in NASW’s own actions and its Code of Ethics.

    The 2029 draft brings that same tension into a new arena: accreditation itself. It retains the language of justice while removing several of the clearest requirements for demonstrating anti-racist practice, justice-directed policy advocacy, and institutional equity efforts. CSWE says the underlying expectations have not changed. The requirements say otherwise.

    The draft also arrives under real political and legal pressure on DEI in higher education. I will not pretend that pressure is imaginary, or that CSWE has no legitimate reason to consider it. But it raises an important question:

    If we abandon our commitments in the face of adversity, were they ever values to begin with?

    How to Read the EPAS: From Commitments to Requirements

    The 2029 draft describes itself as “both a philosophical document and an accountability mechanism.” Those two functions are connected, not separate.

    The EPAS moves from broad to specific. The introduction and educational policies say what social work values. Each competency has a description of the knowledge, values, and skills behind it. Under each description sit observable behaviors. Under each accreditation standard sit compliance statements, which the Board of Accreditation considers “when determining whether the social work program meets the accreditation standards.” Assessment requirements then decide what evidence programs must collect.

    Every layer matters. The draft says a behavior “cannot be demonstrated without incorporating” the knowledge and values in its competency description, and programs must show how their curriculum meets both the policies and the standards.

    But the layers are not equally specific. The further down you go, the more precisely a commitment tells a program what to teach and a site visitor what to check. When a commitment is named in a policy but not carried into a behavior, standard, or compliance statement, it does not disappear. Its application depends more heavily on interpretation.

    That is where the 2029 draft’s changes concentrate. The specific commitment to “social, racial, economic, and environmental justice” survives in several educational policies, but not in any baccalaureate or master’s competency behavior, accreditation standard, or compliance statement.

    The draft anticipates this objection. In its section on professional identity, it says these values have guided the profession for more than a century, and “although the language used to describe them may vary across time, institutions, and political contexts, their substance remains fundamental to the profession.”

    That sentence concedes that political context is shaping the vocabulary. It then asks us to accept that the substance survives. In an accreditation document, changes to required actions are changes in substance. If the commitment is unchanged, the requirements should show it.

    The Evidence: What Changed, Line by Line

    The table compares the adopted 2022 EPAS with Draft 1 of the 2029 EPAS. Quotation marks indicate direct excerpts, and ellipses mark omitted text. Rows marked “summary” paraphrase longer provisions. Behaviors are labeled as each document numbers them: letters in 2022, numerals in 2029.

    Section2022 EPAS2029 Draft 1
    Core values list (EP 1.0)“Service, social justice, the dignity and worth of the person… are among the core values of social work.”“Graduates are expected to embody the profession’s core values of service, fairness, dignity and worth of the person…”
    Purpose (EP 1.0)“its quest for social, racial, economic, and environmental justice; the creation of conditions that facilitate the realization of human rights”“the active pursuit of fairness; the creation of conditions that facilitate the realization of human dignity and respect”
    Competency 2 titleAdvance Human Rights and Social, Racial, Economic, and Environmental JusticePromote Dignity, Respect, and Justice for All
    Competency 2 description“advocate for and engage in strategies to eliminate oppressive structural barriers to ensure that social resources, rights, and responsibilities are distributed equitably”“advocate and implement strategies for increasing access to resources and services that promote the dignity, respect, and justice of all…”
    Behavior 3(a) / 3(1)“demonstrate anti-racist and anti-oppressive social work practice at the individual, family, group, organizational, community, research, and policy levels”“apply the person-in-environment perspective in practice at the individual, family, group, organizational, community, research, and policy levels”
    Behavior 5(b) / 5(2)“apply critical thinking to analyze, formulate, and advocate for policies that advance human rights and social, racial, economic, and environmental justice”“demonstrate an understanding of how to influence policy formulation, analysis, implementation, and evaluation”
    Behavior 8(b) / 8(2)“incorporate culturally responsive methods to negotiate, mediate, and advocate with and on behalf of clients and constituencies”“facilitate effective transitions and/or endings with clients and constituencies that advance mutually agreed-upon goals”
    Behavior 9(b) / 9(2)“critically analyze outcomes and apply evaluation findings to improve practice effectiveness with individuals, families, groups, organizations, and communities”“critically analyze evaluation findings, including the influence of structural, environmental, technological, economic, and systemic factors on outcomes”
    Generalist practice: methods (EP 3.1 / B/M4.1)“generalist practitioners use a range of prevention and intervention methods in their practice…”“generalist practitioners use a range of research-informed intervention methods in their practice…”
    Generalist practice: levels (EP 3.1 / B/M4.1)“The generalist practitioner identifies with the social work profession and applies ethical principles and critical thinking in practice at the micro, mezzo, and macro levels.”“The generalist practitioner applies ethical principles and critical thinking in practice and is proactive in responding to the influence of context on professional practice.”
    Program design element 2.0Anti-Racism, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion: students “develop a commitment to dismantling systems of oppression, such as racism”Social Work Perspective: students “develop an awareness of positionality, power, privilege, and difference”
    Assessment, AS 5.0.2 (summary)A systematic plan to assess at least one ADEI effort in the implicit curriculum, review the outcomes, and make changes linked to the dataOpportunities for graduating students to give feedback on advising, the person-in-environment perspective, and readiness for practice, with review and linked changes
    Admissions (AS 4.1.1 / 3.1.1)“equitable and inclusive, with particular attention to underrepresented as well as historically and currently oppressed groups”“fair and accessible, considering the applicant’s academic readiness, personal context, and lived experience”

    The substitutions are not universal. Human rights, equity, and inclusive practices still appear in parts of the draft. But across these provisions, named commitments to equity, human rights, and anti-oppressive practice are repeatedly replaced by broader language of fairness, dignity, access, and context.

    Three Central Losses

    1. Anti-Racist and Anti-Oppressive Competence

    In 2022, Competency 3 required students to “demonstrate anti-racist and anti-oppressive social work practice” at every level, from individuals to policy. The 2029 behavior keeps the same structure and the same levels. It swaps in the person-in-environment perspective.

    Person-in-environment is foundational to social work. It was also already required in 2022, alongside anti-racist practice. The draft does not add ecological analysis that was missing. It removes a distinct requirement to demonstrate competence in confronting racism and oppression.

    The description changed with it. Gone are racism and oppression as named forces shaping human experience, the “forms and mechanisms of oppression and discrimination,” and intersectionality as a framework. The draft retains identities, lived experience, cultural humility, and privilege, while removing the explicit account of racism, discrimination, and systemic oppression that previously organized the competency.

    2. Policy and Intervention Action

    This is a particularly consequential change for macro practice. In 2022, Behavior 5(b) required students to “analyze, formulate, and advocate for policies.” In the draft, Behavior 5(2) requires them to “demonstrate an understanding of how to influence” policy.

    Consider a hypothetical policy assignment. A student could explain how a benefits eligibility rule might be changed, and even identify who would need to be persuaded, without ever drafting the revision, submitting public comment, or engaging an affected constituency. Under the draft, that student could still be assessed as competent in policy practice. The draft does not stop students from advocating. It removes formulation and advocacy from the policy actions every graduate must demonstrate.

    Competency 8 shows the same pattern. Behavior 8(b) required students to “negotiate, mediate, and advocate with and on behalf of clients and constituencies.” Those are core skills for coalition work, organizational change, and constituency representation. The draft replaces that behavior with transitions and endings, which the 2022 narrative already covered.

    Transitions and endings matter at every level of practice, but nothing required the profession to drop advocacy in order to elevate them. Across Competencies 2, 5, and 8, advocacy goes from three assessed behaviors to one.

    Evaluation follows suit. Competency 9 makes one especially useful improvement: it places structural analysis directly in an observable behavior. But Behavior 9(b) required students to “apply evaluation findings to improve practice effectiveness.” Behavior 9(2) stops at critical analysis. The narrative still ties evaluation to improvement. The behavior should too.

    3. Dedicated Equity Assessment

    Under the 2022 standards, programs had to identify at least one ADEI effort in the implicit curriculum, build an assessment plan for it, review the outcomes, and make changes clearly linked to the data. It was the only part of the implicit curriculum with its own dedicated assessment requirement.

    The draft replaces it with required opportunities for graduating students to give feedback on advising, the person-in-environment perspective, and readiness for practice. Student feedback is valuable. It is not equivalent to assessing an institutional equity effort. A program could meet the new requirement without ever examining racism, exclusion, or inequity in its own learning environment.

    The feedback population matters too. Students who leave a program may hold important evidence about exclusion, inaccessible support, or institutional barriers. A requirement limited to graduating students does not ensure those experiences are heard.

    Smaller Changes That Point the Same Way

    The 2022 definition of generalist practice said practitioners use “prevention and intervention methods” and apply ethical principles “at the micro, mezzo, and macro levels.” The draft drops both phrases. In the entire 2029 draft, the word “macro” now appears only in the practice doctorate sections. The five client systems remain, and field education still requires opportunities with organizations and communities. But the definition loses its explicit preventive orientation and its explicit affirmation of macro practice.

    Competency 2 shifts from eliminating “oppressive structural barriers” so resources are “distributed equitably” to promoting “fairness and equal opportunity.” Fair processes and equal opportunity matter. The NASW Code of Ethics names them as part of social justice. They are not substitutes for examining how power, institutional rules, and resources produce unequal burdens and benefits. Macro practice has to ask both questions. The draft still asks students to assess how power and resources are distributed, but it no longer states this competency’s objective as eliminating oppressive structural barriers and ensuring equitable distribution.

    What Survives, and the Consistency Problem

    A fair reading has to acknowledge what the draft keeps. Quite a lot survives.

    • The generalist practice policy says practitioners “advocate for human rights and social, racial, economic, and environmental justice.”
    • The field education policy says students apply social work values “to advance social, racial, economic, and environmental justice.”
    • The specialized practice policy commits master’s students to research and advocacy aimed at “changing structural inequities.”
    • A new theme, “Policy and Organizational Impact on Outcomes,” calls for critical examination of child welfare, criminal justice, healthcare, housing, and education, and how laws and institutional practices produce different outcomes across populations.
    • Competency 2’s behaviors still require practice that promotes “dignity, respect, and justice” and advocacy that increases access to resources and services.
    • Competency 1 still requires students to apply the NASW Code of Ethics.

    These are real commitments. Several are exactly the macro language I would want in any accreditation document. That is what makes the rest of the draft so hard to defend.

    For baccalaureate and master’s education, the named justice commitments are most explicit in policies and least consistently carried into behaviors and compliance requirements.

    The generalist and field policies name social, racial, economic, and environmental justice. No baccalaureate or master’s behavior, standard, or compliance statement does. The new theme on policy and institutional outcomes is the most compelling macro text in the draft. No standard expressly identifies that theme and requires programs to demonstrate how they implement it.

    Whatever the committee intended, the effect is the same: the document affirms commitments it no longer clearly requires students or programs to demonstrate.

    Three inconsistencies make the point concrete.

    The values list and the Code. The NASW Code of Ethics names social justice as a core value. The draft requires students to apply that Code, then lists the values graduates must embody with “social justice” replaced by “fairness.” A neighboring sentence uses “justice” instead. The EPAS should name the same core value as the Code it requires students to follow.

    The doctoral standard. Accreditation Standard D4.3.3 requires practice doctorate programs to explain how they prepare “doctoral leaders in addressing… human rights and social, racial, economic, and environmental justice.” The draft names those justice domains in a doctoral accreditation standard, but not in any parallel baccalaureate or master’s standard. There is no reason the commitment cannot be equally explicit, at an appropriate level, throughout social work education.

    The population list. When the new theme lists the populations across which students should analyze differential outcomes, it names race, disability status, religion, national origin, immigration status, age, and sexual orientation. Sex, gender identity, and class do not appear, although the draft’s own Competency 3 includes them. That omission should be corrected for consistency.

    Political Pressure and CSWE’s Response

    Our current political environment matters and must be acknowledged in any honest critique.

    On April 23, 2025, the President signed Executive Order 14279, “Reforming Accreditation to Strengthen Higher Education.” It directs the Secretary of Education to hold accreditors accountable, including through denial, suspension, or termination of recognition, for what it calls “unlawful discrimination in accreditation-related activity under the guise of” DEI initiatives.

    The order does not directly threaten CSWE’s own standing. As CSWE noted in April 2025, it is recognized by the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA), not the Department of Education. The pressure runs mainly through universities, state legislatures, and programs caught between their accreditor and their state law. According to CSWE, legislation restricting or banning DEI has been introduced or passed in 30 states.

    Do No Harm and the False Dichotomy

    Pressure on CSWE has not come only from government. In a May 13, 2026 letter to CSWE President and CEO Halaevalu Vakalahi and to the president of CHEA, the advocacy group Do No Harm asked CSWE to “commit unequivocally” to removing all references to anti-racism and DEI from its accreditation standards. The letter specifically cited Competencies 2 and 3, the anti-racist and anti-oppressive language in Competencies 4, 5, and 9, and the ADEI governance requirement in Educational Policy 4.3. Each of those provisions is removed or rewritten in Draft 1.

    What deserves a second read from every macro practitioner is the letter’s reasoning. Do No Harm argues that the 2022 standards encourage programs “to treat students as activists-in-training, at the expense of clinical education,” and calls them “antithetical to core principles of healthcare.”

    This is a perfect example of clinical drift stated as a policy demand. The letter judges social work education through a healthcare lens. It places anti-racist policy practice and structural justice requirements on the “activism” side of a supposed divide from clinical preparation, as though the two were opposed rather than parts of the profession’s dual mandate: responsibility both to individuals and to the social conditions that shape their lives.

    Social work has never been only a clinical profession. The NASW Code of Ethics, in Section 6.04, commits social workers to social and political action. Person-in-environment, the very perspective Draft 1 elevates, exists because individual problems cannot be separated from the systems that produce them. Advocacy is not activism layered on top of social work. It is social work.

    Now look again at what Draft 1 weakened most: the policy formulation and advocacy behavior, the negotiation, mediation, and advocacy behavior, and the explicit naming of macro practice and prevention in the definition of generalist practice. Those are the parts of social work education most easily caricatured as activism. None of this proves the letter shaped the draft. Even so, the alignment matters as a question of professional direction.

    When social work accepts the premise that clinical competence requires retreating from advocacy, it validates the very drift that has been hollowing out the profession for decades.

    What CSWE Says

    CSWE has explained its reasoning. On its 2029 EPAS page, it says it will not ask programs to break the law, that the proposed language is meant to let programs keep addressing barriers while meeting their legal obligations, and that the changing legal landscape has made compliance costly and lawful guidance increasingly difficult. In an October 14 letter posted there, CSWE leadership wrote that while the terminology “has evolved from the ADEI-specific language used in the 2022 EPAS,” the “underlying values and expectations have not changed.”

    This is the claim the article tests. The expectations have changed in identifiable places. Requiring students to advocate for policy is not the same as requiring them to understand how advocacy works. Assessing a named institutional equity effort is not the same as collecting feedback about readiness for practice.

    These concerns are already on CSWE’s own revision agenda. In an October 20 update on the same page, President and CEO Halaevalu Vakalahi and Executive Director of Accreditation Collina Cooke identified areas the writing committee will need to reassess. They cited “some of the language substitutions related to the core principles of social work,” and calls for “stronger and more explicit language around addressing and combating racism” and around environmental justice. That feedback, they wrote, will inform the second draft in 2027.

    That acknowledgment matters. However, the true test will be what returns to the competencies, behaviors, standards, and assessment requirements.

    A Targeted Alternative Already Existed

    In January 2026 guidance, CSWE said it “remains steadfast in its commitment to the current standards and competencies.” Programs in states with enacted restrictions could use alternative language, but only after identifying the law and showing how their curriculum still aligned with the competencies. Everyone else met the 2022 EPAS as written. Draft 1 instead reduces explicit requirements for every program, including programs in states with no restrictions at all.

    CSWE has explained why the targeted approach has become harder to administer. It has not shown why those difficulties require replacing demonstrated policy advocacy with understanding, removing a distinct anti-racist practice requirement, or eliminating dedicated equity assessment, rather than strengthening the accommodation for the programs that legally need one.

    The Test: Rhetoric Verses Action

    Consider the sequence. In June 2021, NASW formally apologized for racist practices in American social work, acknowledging that the profession had “not always lived up to our mission.” In 2022, CSWE adopted accreditation standards that named anti-racism explicitly and required programs to demonstrate it. In October 2026, under the current wave of political and legal pressure, CSWE released the first draft of the next standards for public comment, and it removes anti-racism from the document entirely.

    Social work does not exist in a vacuum. Our institutions face real conflicts between obligations, and the NASW Code itself recognizes that ethical responsibilities sometimes collide. However, CSWE owes the profession a clear account of what it will preserve, what it proposes to change, and how those choices protect the people the profession is meant to serve.

    We ask more than that of individual social workers. The NASW Code tells us to challenge social injustice. We ask new practitioners to push back on supervisors, courts, and agencies when those systems harm clients, knowing it may cost them.

    Values are not determined by rhetoric, but by action. A commitment that disappears from the requirements while remaining in the profession’s public identity begins to function as branding.

    What the Draft Communicates, and What It Risks

    Accreditation standards are written for programs, but they are public documents. The communities we serve have a right to ask:

    What assurance does this draft offer that social work graduates will be prepared to recognize and challenge systems that perpetuate harm?

    Read as written, the honest answer is: less than the last one did. Regardless of intent, a profession that apologizes for its racism, writes anti-racism into its standards, and then removes it under pressure sends an unacceptable message: our commitment to the hardships of the people we serve only holds until it begins to cost the profession something.

    My concern is that these changes could reinforce the epistemic erosion spiral I have described elsewhere. In that spiral, clinical drift narrows the profession and erodes trust among system-impacted communities. That distrust filters lived experience out of the workforce, which weakens macro practice.

    Draft 1 touches each stage of the spiral. It drops macro practice and prevention from the definition of generalist practice. It withdraws explicit commitments without a clear account of how their substance survives. It removes the admissions requirement to attend to underrepresented and historically oppressed groups, even as it welcomes lived experience as an admissions consideration. And it reduces the behaviors that require students to demonstrate policy advocacy, negotiation, and the use of evaluation findings.

    These are argued risks, not observed outcomes. But accreditation standards shape curricula for years at a time, and the moment to name these risks is before they are adopted.

    The Case for the Current Draft

    There are valid arguments worth considering for the 2029 EPAS draft in its current form.

    “Broader language protects programs.” This is CSWE’s own argument, and it has weight. Programs in restrictive states face real legal exposure, and faculty there are spending time on compliance instead of teaching. If programs lose accreditation or close, students and communities lose a pipeline of social workers, often in the places that need them most.

    Legal flexibility and demonstrable competence are not mutually exclusive. CSWE could permit alternative terminology while specifying the substantive outcomes that terminology must preserve: that graduates can recognize and confront racism, formulate and advocate for policy, and use evidence to change practice. That moves the debate from vocabulary to requirements, which is where it belongs.

    “Parts of the draft are stronger.” True. Competency 9 places structural analysis in an observable behavior. The new theme on policy and institutional outcomes is excellent. Competency 10 asks students to examine how power and inequity shape access to technology.

    But look at where the gains landed. Analysis gained. Action lost. In these revisions, the requirements for analyzing systems become more explicit while several requirements for acting to change them become less explicit. For macro practice, that trade runs the wrong direction.

    “The 2022 framework narrowed inquiry.” Twis and colleagues make the most serious version of this argument in an April 2026 editorial in Research on Social Work Practice, published before Draft 1 was released. They propose replacing the EPAS emphasis on ADEI with epistemic pluralism, open inquiry, and constructive disagreement. They write that they “favor working against racism,” and they propose assessable requirements: comparative treatment of competing frameworks in core syllabi, protections for dissent, and student learning outcomes on representing opposing views fairly and justifying interventions with evidence. Their call for fewer pedagogical directives overlaps with the removal of some prescriptive requirements in Draft 1.

    That argument deserves engagement, not dismissal. But Draft 1 is not their proposal. It adds none of their assessable pluralism requirements. One alternative they identify is liberal rights-based frameworks, yet the draft does not require engagement with that tradition, and it removes human rights from the purpose clause and from both Competency 2 behaviors. The revision cannot be defended as replacing one framework with a clearly specified pluralist alternative. In the provisions examined here, it makes important justice-directed requirements less explicit.

    A profession can welcome debate about how to confront racism while still requiring its graduates to be competent at confronting it.

    “Programs can add competencies.” Also true. Programs committed to anti-racist, justice-directed practice can keep teaching it, and many will.

    That is the problem stated another way. When explicit requirements become optional emphasis, preparation becomes uneven. Preparation to confront racism would become more dependent on local program priorities and state legal context, rather than an equally explicit national requirement. Accreditation exists so that the floor does not depend on the luck of the draw.

    What to Ask For

    This is Draft 1, and CSWE has said a second draft will follow in 2027. The comment period is the moment the next standards get shaped. The strongest comments will connect wording to required competence: what students must demonstrate, what programs must assess, and what evidence reviewers must examine.

    Three Priorities

    1. Restore action to the behaviors. Behavior 5(2) should again require students to analyze, formulate, and advocate for policies that advance human rights and social, racial, economic, and environmental justice. Behavior 8(2) should restore negotiation, mediation, and advocacy alongside transitions and endings. Behavior 9(2) should restore the requirement to apply evaluation findings, and extend it explicitly to improving practice, programs, and policy.
    2. Keep a distinct, demonstrable requirement for anti-racist and anti-oppressive practice. Person-in-environment should sit alongside it, as it did in 2022, not replace it. If CSWE permits alternative terminology for legally constrained programs, it should define the substantive competence that terminology must preserve.
    3. Restore dedicated equity assessment. Programs should assess a named institutional equity effort, review the outcomes, and make changes linked to the data. Graduating-student feedback should supplement that assessment, not replace it. CSWE should also go a step beyond both versions and require feedback from students who leave before graduating.

    Secondary Fixes

    • Make baccalaureate and master’s standards as explicit about social, racial, economic, and environmental justice as doctoral standard D4.3.3, at a level appropriate to each degree.
    • Make environmental justice competence separately identifiable in curriculum and assessment, including how students identify and respond to environmental injustices affecting communities. The 2022 standards already required practice and policy advocacy that advance environmental justice. This would make that commitment more specific, not merely restore its wording.
    • Restore “social justice” to the core values graduates are expected to embody, consistent with the NASW Code of Ethics.
    • Restore “micro, mezzo, and macro” and “prevention” to the definition of generalist practice.
    • Tie the “Policy and Organizational Impact on Outcomes” theme to an accreditation standard, and add sex, gender identity, and class to its population list, consistent with Competency 3.
    • Show why the administrative difficulties CSWE describes require these specific substantive changes, rather than a stronger targeted accommodation.

    How to Comment

    The public comment period closes at 11:59 p.m. Eastern (10:59 p.m. Central) on November 20, 2026. Comments go through CSWE’s online feedback survey, linked from the 2029 EPAS page.

    • Cite section numbers and quote the draft’s own language.
    • Lead with the inconsistency. Show CSWE where the draft already commits to justice, and ask it to require what it already claims.
    • Bring your own practice. Field instructors, faculty, students, and practitioners with lived experience each see consequences the drafting committee may not.
    • Share it. Program directors, field offices, and NASW chapters can submit coordinated recommendations grounded in their educational and practice experience.

    Conclusion: Say It, Then Require It

    Social work has never lacked words about justice. We have mission statements, apologies, strategic plans, and a code of ethics full of them. What we have repeatedly lacked is the discipline to turn those words into action, and to maintain those efforts when they become inconvenient.

    The 2029 EPAS draft shows whether the profession has learned that lesson. As written, it has not. It keeps the language of justice while removing several of the clearest requirements to demonstrate it.

    It does not have to stay that way. CSWE’s own leadership has acknowledged the concerns. The second draft is still being written. What returns to the competencies, behaviors, standards, and assessment requirements will tell us whether those concerns were heard.

    The communities we serve have heard plenty of promises from our profession. This is a chance to show them a commitment that holds.

    Say it in the preamble. Require it in the standards. Anything less is lip service.

  • The Credentialing Apparatus: How Social Work Institutions Filter Out Lived Experience

    Image depicting the credentialing apparatus with gated barriers labeled licensure, accreditation, debt, and conference, highlighting unequal access to professional pathways.

    The Credentialing Apparatus in Social Work

    Social work does not have a values problem on paper. It has a structural problem in practice.

    Across the profession, the language is consistent. Mission statements center equity. Accreditation standards emphasize anti-oppressive practice. Conferences elevate lived experience as essential to systems change. The words are not the issue. They are repeated often enough to feel foundational, providing a moral veneer for the profession’s institutional identity.

    Beneath that veneer, however, the infrastructure is doing something else entirely.

    The same systems that claim to prioritize lived experience are quietly determining who is allowed to count as a “professional” in the first place. In doing so, they are filtering out the very people whose knowledge is essential to the justice social work claims to seek.

    This is not a hidden problem. It is simply one that is rarely named directly, because doing so requires calling attention to the interlocking institutions that anchor the profession itself.

    So, let’s name it directly.

    The Association of Social Work Boards (ASWB), Council on Social Work Education (CSWE), National Association of Social Workers (NASW), and accredited MSW programs do not operate in isolation. Together, they form an integrated system that governs entry into the profession, defines what counts as legitimate knowledge, and shapes who has access to decision-making spaces.

    In the field of sociology, this is known as a credentialing apparatus. In practice, it functions as a high-precision gatekeeping system.

    This apparatus is far from neutral. It systematically privileges institutionally produced, formally credentialed knowledge, while marginalizing the lived experience expertise held by system-impacted individuals.

    The result is not just exclusion at the margins. It is a narrowing of the profession’s epistemic base. One that directly undermines our stated commitment to justice and community-informed practice.

    This is not a story of individual malice. Many within these institutions are deeply committed to social work’s values. Instead, this is a story of structural logic. Institutions are designed to reproduce themselves. Over time, they optimize for legitimacy, control, and continuity. When left unchecked, these institutional priorities begin to override the values and mission they were built to uphold.

    The consequence is not abstract. The communities social work claims to serve are shaped by systems that have filtered out their knowledge before it ever reaches the table.


    Licensure Exam Bias

    To understand how the credentialing apparatus functions, we should start with its most empirically unambiguous tool: the ASWB licensure examination.

    In 2022, ASWB released a comprehensive analysis of licensing exam pass rates covering a decade of test results, disaggregated by race and ethnicity. The findings shocked the profession. Among first-time test-takers for the Clinical exam, the credential required for independent practice, white candidates passed at a rate of 83.9 percent. Black candidates passed at 45.0 percent.

    We often talk about this as a “39-point gap,” but that framing is too soft. Instead, we should look at the failure rate, the actual speed at which the filter operates.

    First time white exam-takers failed at a rate of 16.1%, compared to 55% for Black exam-takers. Put another way: Black examinees were over 3.4 times more likely to fail than their white peers.

    This is not a minor disparity. It is a consistent pattern, produced over time, and documented by the very organization administering the exam.

    ASWB’s own leadership acknowledged that systemic and institutional racism, specifically anti-Blackness, is “core to the racial disparities evidenced” in these outcomes. They further clarified that the disparity reflects historic and structural conditions, not a lack of competence among Black candidates.

    Read that again.

    The institution responsible for administering the profession’s primary gatekeeping exam has publicly affirmed that its outcomes reflect structural racism, not candidate deficiency.

    And, yet, the exam remains in place as a requirement for advancement.

    This is the credentialing apparatus in its purest form.

    While the clinical exam does not fully determine who can enter the social work profession, it does influence who can advance within it. Who can practice independently, and who gains access to the forms of credibility, autonomy, and compensation that shape long-term career trajectories.

    In that sense, it functions as a high-impact filter. It does not just sort for knowledge. It redistributes opportunity.

    The consequences are tangible. A practitioner who has deep, system-informed lived experience, who has completed their degree, and who is seeking to build a long-term career in social work may encounter a gate that disproportionately blocks advancement for people who share their background.

    Over time, those patterns accumulate. They shape who remains in the profession, who advances into leadership, and whose knowledge is positioned as authoritative within the field.


    Contradictory Accreditation Standards

    CSWE’s 2022 Educational Policy and Accreditation Standards are saturated with the language of equity.

    Educational Policy 2.0, titled Anti-Racism, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, requires programs to integrate ADEI principles across the curriculum, cultivate cultural humility, and recognize the role of learning environments in modeling inclusive practice. A 2024 curriculum resource further encourages programs to consider how students’ lived experience shapes both practice skills and their understanding of the populations they serve.

    The message is clear: Lived experience matters.

    However, embedded in the same document, Accreditation Standard 4.1.5 states: “The program does not grant social work course credit for life experience or previous work experience.”

    That isn’t an ambiguous provision. It is a formal prohibition, enforceable through the accreditation review process.

    Whatever lived experience a prospective student brings, however deep their firsthand knowledge of the systemic flaws social work seeks to address, that knowledge cannot reduce the time, cost, or structural requirements of professional entry. It can be discussed in the classroom, or reflected upon in a learning agreement, but it cannot count.

    This is not a minor inconsistency. It is a structural contradiction.

    Lived experience is pedagogically valued and structurally subordinated within the same document. We invite practitioners with lived experience to be seen while ensuring they cannot disrupt the traditional academic metrics that govern professional entry.

    The language used is also quite telling. Programs are told they “may consider” the lived experience of their students. That phrasing does important work. It frames experiential knowledge as optional context, not recognized expertise.

    This pattern extends beyond the classroom and into field education. My analysis of 16 MSW field education manuals, published in The Practicum as Creative Laboratory, found that programs routinely impose legitimacy criteria that systematically exclude grassroots, peer-led, and lived experience-led organizations from serving as field placement sites. Organizations are often required to demonstrate professional liability insurance, minimum years of operation, formal organizational structures, and established written policies and procedures.

    Each requirement is individually defensible. Together, they create cumulative barriers that favor established clinical agencies and effectively exclude mutual aid groups, community organizing collectives, and organizations led by people with direct experience of the systems social work seeks to change.

    The most striking finding from that analysis: not one of the 16 programs explicitly informed students that CSWE’s own standards permit external MSW supervision when programs assume responsibility for reinforcing a social work perspective. The flexibility exists, but programs do not advertise it.

    As a result, students and agencies often assume that on-site MSW supervision is required. Under that assumption, entire categories of potential placement sites, many of them rich in macro learning opportunities and grounded in lived experience leadership, are quietly excluded from consideration.

    This is how the contradiction sustains itself.

    The standards gesture toward inclusion while the structures of implementation maintain exclusion.


    Who Gets to Shape the Discourse

    The CSWE Annual Conference is the flagship gathering for social work education scholarship. It is the space where the knowledge claims of the field are debated, where research is presented, and where the profession’s intellectual agenda is shaped.

    The 2026 conference theme is Rooted in Resilience: Honoring the Past, Grounding the Present. The call for proposals invites presentations on honoring ancestral knowledge and traditional helping practices, the role of storytelling and oral histories in social work education, and resilience in marginalized communities. Lived experience knowledge is positioned as the intellectual center of the conference’s scholarly agenda.

    The participation requirements tell a different story.

    The 2026 CSWE Conference Presenter Responsibility Agreement states, without qualification, that each presenter listed on the proposal must be registered for the full conference and that registration must be paid in full. Presenters who do not comply by July 31, 2026, will be removed from the program. This requirement applies regardless of institutional affiliation, employment status, or financial circumstances.

    The most telling detail: as of the proposal submission deadline (February 12, 2026), conference registration pricing was not publicly available. Presenters were required to agree in advance to pay an unspecified full registration cost. The financial commitment had to be made before the financial cost was disclosed.

    Whatever the eventual price, the mechanism itself works in direct opposition of the stated theme.

    The community organizer, peer specialist, or system-impacted practitioner who lacks an institutional budget is given a choice: pay an undisclosed toll or be erased from the discourse. The conference theme celebrates their voice, while conference policy quietly filters them out.

    This reproduces exactly the dynamic found in our education and licensure: Lived experience is rhetorically centered, but structurally subordinated.

    When we treat participation as a pay-to-play endeavor, we risk turning national discourse into a closed loop. One where the lived experience of marginalized communities is filtered through the voices of those who can afford the ticket.


    The Financial Filter

    The MSW degree is the entry credential for advanced social work practice. What that credential costs, relative to what it pays, should be considered a first-order justice issue by any organization committed to an equitable and representative profession.

    A CSWE and NASW workforce survey found that 2019 MSW graduates carried a mean total educational debt of approximately $66,000, while starting salaries averaged just $47,100. This debt-to-income ratio is among the most unfavorable of any master’s degree field in the country.

    That burden is not evenly distributed.

    The same workforce survey found that Black and African American graduates carried mean debt of approximately $92,000. Hispanic graduates carried approximately $79,000. Both groups entered the profession with debt loads approaching or exceeding twice their starting salary.

    NASW’s 2024 comment letter to the U.S. Department of Education acknowledged that educational costs are high, compensation is persistently low, and debt burden falls unevenly, with women and Black and Hispanic social workers carrying heavier loads.

    The consequences for the field are clear. The people most likely to carry the lived experience knowledge essential to systems reform (child welfare, carceral systems, poverty, housing instability, etc.) are the very people most likely to be blocked by these financial walls.

    When professional entry requires a $90,000 investment for a $47,000 return, we are not “building a workforce.” We are performing a sophisticated form of epistemic filtering. We are ensuring that the leadership of our profession remains a closed circle of those who can afford the debt, while the practitioners social work most urgently needs are priced out before they can ever reach the table.


    The Accountability Gap

    The organizations that form the credentialing apparatus have no shortage of internal committees. ASWB publishes research on its own disparities; CSWE commissions diversity task forces; NASW issues anti-racism statements. What they lack is meaningful external accountability for equity outcomes.

    There is no external body with the authority to require ASWB to develop alternative credentialing pathways because its existing examination produces racially stratified results. There is no mechanism through which students, community members, or practitioners with lived experience can compel CSWE to revise Standard 4.1.5 or reform its conference participation policy. There is no external body that evaluates whether NASW’s governance and employment practices align with its own Code of Ethics.

    Self-regulation, without external constraint, has predictable limits.

    Even where transparency exists, accountability does not necessarily follow.

    Publicly available Form 990 filings show CEOs and Presidents at NASW, CSWE, and ASWB are compensated in the $290,000 to $330,000 range. While these figures are individually defensible within nonprofit governance standards, they also reflect a level of institutional insulation.

    They sit alongside a professional workforce with median earnings around $61,000, a licensure system that produces racially disparate outcomes, and an educational pipeline that requires many entrants to assume debt that vastly exceeds their starting salary.

    The gap is not simply financial. It is structural distance from consequence.

    That distance becomes most visible when institutions act in ways that directly affect practitioners.

    In 2025, NASW moved to restructure its state chapter system, eliminating fourteen executive director positions despite opposition from multiple state chapters, including votes of no confidence and board resignations in several states. The process was widely described by practitioners as opaque and top-down, reflecting governance dynamics that violate NASW’s own code of ethics and stated commitments to participation and shared power.

    The pattern across all of these institutions is the same. Data are generated, statements are issued, committees are formed, and structural change does not occur.

    Without external accountability, the profession’s justice mandate remains a rhetorical tool used to legitimize a system that centers institutional survival over systemic change.


    The Upstream Architecture of the Spiral

    The epistemic erosion spiral describes how clinical drift narrows social work’s public identity, which erodes trust in marginalized communities, discourages system-impacted individuals from pursuing macro pathways, weakens macro practice capacity, and ultimately reinforces clinical dominance. Each stage accelerates the next.

    This analysis begs the question: Where does the spiral’s energy come from?

    The answer is not clinical drift as an abstract force. Drift is a downstream phenomenon.

    The energy is generated upstream by an interlocking credentialing apparatus. It comes from structures that make professional entry financially prohibitive for the practitioners most essential to macro work. From accreditation standards that prohibit lived experience from counting toward the credential. From field education requirements that exclude peer-led and grassroots organizations. From a licensure system that produces racially stratified outcomes and remains in place. From participation policies that require payment to enter the spaces where the profession’s knowledge claims are shaped.

    The spiral does not begin in practice settings. It is engineered by the very institutions charged with developing and sustaining the profession.

    This distinction matters for how we think about reform. If the problem is drift, the solution is reorientation: more macro content in curricula, more advocacy for macro roles, more rhetorical commitment to systems change. The profession has been trying these solutions for decades, yet the spiral continues to accelerate.

    If the problem is design, the solution requires naming the architects. We must hold the profession’s own institutions accountable for outcomes that contradict their stated values. It requires stating plainly that the ASWB’s continued administration of an examination with documented 3.4x failure rates for Black candidates, CSWE’s prohibition on crediting lived experience while invoking it rhetorically, and NASW’s centralization of governance authority while claiming commitment to community voice are not organizational imperfections.

    They are structural choices with structural consequences.


    What Structural Reform Actually Requires

    This is not an argument for dismantling credentialing or abandoning the institutions that sustain the profession. It is an argument about the level at which change must occur.

    The reforms required are structural, not rhetorical. And the profession has not yet been honest about what that actually entails.

    It would mean the ASWB developing alternative credentialing pathways in practice, not continuing to study them in theory, for practitioners who are excluded by an examination its own data show produces racially stratified outcomes.

    It would mean the CSWE revising Standard 4.1.5 to allow for the formal recognition of lived experience as a form of knowledge, and restructuring conference participation so that contributing to professional discourse is not contingent on absorbing an undisclosed financial cost.

    It would mean the NASW building governance mechanisms that provide practitioners and community members with real influence over institutional decision-making, not participation that is primarily symbolic.

    It would mean treating the cost structure of the MSW degree as a justice issue, and advocating accordingly for expanded loan forgiveness, funded field placements, and tuition equity for the students most burdened by the current system.

    None of these changes are technically complex. All of them are institutionally difficult.

    They require acknowledging what the current structure is doing, who it is excluding, and how those outcomes contradict the profession’s stated commitments.

    Until that acknowledgment occurs, reform efforts will continue to orbit the problem without changing it.


    A Closing Word to Practitioners

    If you are a social worker who has felt the weight of a profession that claims your values but does not always honor them, this analysis is not abstract.

    You have seen what happens when someone with deep community knowledge cannot pass a licensing exam built on assumptions they had no role in shaping. You have seen grassroots organizations denied as field placements because they lack the right institutional markers. You have seen the people with the most to teach treated as the most difficult to include.

    To the practitioners carrying lived experience of the systems social work claims to address: Your knowledge is not a liability to be managed. It is a form of epistemic authority that no degree confers and no training can replicate. The fact that our current institutions have failed to build structures adequate to that reality is a structural failure, not a personal one.

    The epistemic regeneration spiral describes a different future: one where visible macro effectiveness rebuilds community trust, trust opens pathways for lived experience leadership, and that leadership strengthens our collective capacity for justice. This spiral is possible, but it requires us to move beyond “honoring” lived experience toward investing in it.

    The profession has the evidence it needs. The question is whether we have the institutional will to act on what we already know.


    This article is part of an ongoing research and analysis series examining professional legitimacy, lived experience leadership, and macro practice in social work. The full academic treatment of this argument has been submitted as a working paper on SSRN, and will be linked here when approved. Related frameworks include the Epistemic Erosion Spiral, the Epistemic Regeneration Spiral, and Deafening Silence: NASW Restructuring and the Fear of Speaking Up.